The Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services (then
known as the Office of Financial and Insurance Regulation, or OFIR)
found in 2008 that Flaherty, through his brokerage, Alternative
Insurance Services (AIS) had misappropriated more than $1.3 million in
premium funds for his own personal use. The AG’s office said Flaherty
began skimming small amounts of insurance premium paid by local
insurance agents on behalf of their customers, rather than sending them
to insurance companies, as far back as 1999.
OFIR revoked AIS’ license and ordered the agency to stop selling
insurance in Michigan in 2008. In 2010, the OFIR petitioned the court to
have Flaherty abide by the terms of a restitution plan to which he had
previously agreed. The OFIR said he never complied with the consent
order, under which he was to pay restitution of $1,329,086 to 18
insurers and surplus lines general agents.
The AG’s investigation found that Flaherty had started skimming small amounts of insurance premium.
According to the AG’s office, Flaherty used the money to pay for
expensive cars, clothing and even to live in a hotel for over a year,
while he was using additional premiums to pay the mortgage on a home he
owned. Flaherty was able to cover the fraud for years by taking money
from other premiums to cover the money he stole. However, once his
business slowed he was unable to continue covering the fraud.